Robert M.N.
Palmer, The Law Offices of Robert M.N. Palmer, P.C. and Charles
A. Saladino, Saladino Law Firm, for Plaintiff. W. Russell Welsh,
Polsinelli, White, Vardeman & Shalton and William Grubbs for
Defendant.
On September 15, 1990, 34 year-old Jackie Gills was the right
front passenger in his friend's 1988 Ford Escort GT. The car was
equipped with Ford's standard "passive" restraint system: a
motorized shoulder harness, manual lap belt and, Ford contends,
a knee bolster. Mr. Gills had the seat reclined with the
motorized automatic shoulder harness engaged. The manual lap
belt was not engaged. The driver of the vehicle momentarily
dozed off, and the car drifted off the roadway and struck a
culvert. The delta-V was estimated (by both Plaintiff's and
Defendant's experts) to be approximately 30.
At impact, Mr.
Gills submarined beneath the shoulder harness, caught his neck
on the belt, and received severe spinal cord injuries which
rendered him paraplegic.
Plaintiff brought suit against Ford Motor Company on the theory
of design defect, in that a lap belt should have been an
integrated part of the passive restraint system, and that a
"passive system" without such an integrated lap belt is
unreasonably dangerous. Plaintiff further alleged failure to
warn of the need to wear a lap belt and failure to warn of the
dangers of riding with the seat reclined.
The Gills case was
only the second motorized shoulder harness/manual lap belt case
to be tried in the U.S. Trial was before a Louisville, KY jury
July 11-22, 1994, and after 5 days of deliberation, the jury
returned a
$2,500,000 Plaintiff's verdict.